Saturday 29 August 2009


Dr. Nancy Scheper-Hughes, Radical Anthropologist

The following is a transcript of an interview by Neal Conan with Dr. NANCY SCHEPER-HUGHES who gives information on this criminal activity in depth. She clarifies quite a few points regarding Israel and other countries in this report.


This is TALK OF THE NATION. I'm Neal Conan in Washington.

Last week, FBI agents arrested 44 people in northern New Jersey ~ including mayors, legislators and rabbis ~ on corruption charges. Most of the allegations involve bribery and money laundering, but one stands out. Brooklyn Rabbi Levy Izhak Rosenbaum stands accused of trafficking in human kidneys.

A black market in organs may evoke images of faraway places with impoverished donors, shady brokers and seedy clinics, but Rosenbaum's arrest, the first of its kind in the United States, appears to confirm that the buying and selling of human organs is also conducted right here, with transplants by American surgeons in American hospitals. And with 80,000 Americans on the waiting list for a kidney, perhaps the news should come as no real surprise.

We begin with Lindy Washburn, senior writer for health care at The Record, which covers north Jersey. She joins us from member station WBGO in Newark, and thanks very much for being with us today.

Ms. LINDY WASHBURN (Senior Writer, The Record): Glad to be here, thank you.

CONAN: And how does the FBI connect a rabbi in Brooklyn to the black market in human kidneys?

Ms. WASHBURN: The link between all these cases was a cooperating witness that had come to the FBI's attention because he'd been charged with bank fraud. And he apparently knew about Izhak Rosenbaum and called him, saying that he was interested in procuring a kidney on behalf of a friend, the friend being his secretary, who happened to be an undercover FBI agent.

CONAN: So this was a sting operation.

Ms. WASHBURN: It was a sting operation, and her story was that she had an uncle who was very sick with polycystic disease, had been on dialysis for several years and needed to get a transplant. So Dwek called Rosenbaum, and Rosenbaum invited them to his home in Brooklyn, where they went in February of 2008. They go out there, and they ask him about how he gets these kidneys and what his experience is…

CONAN: And we know this because these conversations are tape recorded.

Ms. WASHBURN: Exactly, yes. The complaint quotes from him based on the tape recordings that the undercover agent had made. So he tells them that he would be able to take a blood sample from her uncle and transport it to Israel, and there are hunters there who will find a donor. The cost for this would be $150,000. He says he needs to schmear a lot of people, pay them for their services.

CONAN: Bribe them.

Ms. WASHBURN: Bribe them, exactly, exactly. He's got to deal with the doctors who will screen the donors in Israel with visa services. He has to arrange for babysitters as the donor/seller recovers in the United States, and then he pays the donor. Now, the investigator said at the news conference after the arrests were made that he paid the donor $10,000. So you can see, even if his expenses were around $50,000, he's ~ the profit motive is quite large here.

CONAN: And the tape recordings also have him boasting that he's done this a lot.

Ms. WASHBURN: Right. He even gave them references. And the undercover agent called one of the references, who's identified as Recipient Number 2, a New Jersey man who had procured an organ through Rosenbaum a year earlier and received the transplant at a hospital in the United States, but not in New Jersey, and said everything had gone very well. And the undercover agent, posing as a secretary, said and, you know, why do you think the donor did it? And the recipient said, well, I guess he needed the money.

CONAN: And all of this was done, as you suggest, at a U.S. hospital, and the rabbi was ready to help them with their story. The donor has to go in with the recipient and explain to the hospital why he's doing this.

Ms. WASHBURN: Exactly. So he ~ part of his job is that he's going to coach the ostensible donor, and they're going to concoct a story. He'll need to meet the uncle who's going to receive the kidney. And at one point, the FBI undercover agent says, well, let's just say, he's ~ you know, that they're third cousins.

Ms. WASHBURN: And Rosenbaum says, well, now, a family connection can be checked. It's better if we say he's a friend from the neighborhood, from the synagogue, you know, friend of the children, something like that. And…

CONAN: And this is plausible because there are people who do this altruistically.

Ms. WASHBURN: There are, and there's often, you know, distant cousins who come forward who do this. Transplant surgeons and their teams here in the United States are, you know, trained to screen donors and to, you know, go through a kind of psychological profile and a series of questions with them to weed out this sort of thing.

CONAN: But I guess the allegation, more broadly, is that people are also willing to look the other way.

Ms. WASHBURN: Yes. It's interesting, though, because the fact that he's talking about how he has to coach the seller of the organ seems to indicate that he doesn't have, you know, an actual network connection with the hospitals that are doing this. He's not bribing them. So they are trying to dupe them, but some hospitals may look more carefully at this than others.

CONAN: And is the suggestion that these other people picked up in this big corruption sweep, are they, these bribery and money-laundering charges, are they connected with this, as well?

Ms. WASHBURN: They're separate and distinct. I tried to ask the assistant U.S. attorney about that this morning, and the money, the $10,000 down payment that the undercover agent provided through the confidential witness to Rosenbaum, was deposited in the accounts of some charities that Rosenbaum controlled, but those don't seem to be the same charities that the money-laundering scheme used in the United States.

So the exact relationship among these different entities is not clear. What links them is the FBI's informant, Solomon Dwek, who was a real-estate developer in New Jersey, and you know, has been putting off his either indictment or plea agreement while he engages in these various sting operations.

CONAN: I guess if there is any connection it would come out in trial or other further legal proceedings, in case some of these people end up pleading guilty. And where does the case stand now?

Ms. WASHBURN: Well, the next step would be for either a plea agreement involving Rosenbaum or an indictment, and neither one of those is likely to happen for quite some time, I was told this morning.

CONAN: Thanks very much. We appreciate your time today. Lindy Washburn is a senior writer for health care at The Record of Bergen County in north New Jersey. Thanks very much for being with us today.

Ms. WASHBURN: You're welcome.

CONAN: We turn now to Nancy Scheper-Hughes. She joins us from the campus of the University of California at Berkeley, where she is a professor of medical anthropology. She's also the founder of Organs Watch, a program that researches human organ trafficking around the world, and thanks very much for being with us.

Dr. NANCY SCHEPER-HUGHES (Professor of Medical Anthropology, University of California at Berkeley; Founder, Organs Watch): Thank you, Neal. It's good to be here.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: There's many different routes into buying and selling kidneys. Some are organized by international brokers, as in the case of Izhak Rosenbaum. He was linked to a very, very large and extensive trafficking network that originates in Israel but is in about 12 countries, with brokers placed, like Izhak, in all of these locations.

Some, hunt for kidney sellers, some to hunt on dialysis units to produce people who will travel and take the risk of breaking laws and doing this on faith. You often have to pay, in advance, large portions of money. Some people are brought from Israel and don't know where they're going, which city, which hospital, which country in some cases, because it's a very, very secret operation.

Now, in the United States, what's far more common ~ unfortunately over the last few years and very, very difficult, I think, to control because it doesn't have, you know, a single network that you can kind of trace the tentacles or the, you know, the pyramid structures, which Rosenbaum was involved in ~ in the United States it's a lot of independent brokers who set themselves up through the Internet and, you know, make their arrangements quite locally.

And those brokers, I've communicated with several of them in the States. Sometimes, they're brokering in the States, and sometimes they're brokering with other countries ~ Manila, for example, has been a site that ~ very, very active brokering between patients on dialysis who are willing to travel to Manila and the several hospitals there.

People are more likely to go there than to India, which was the site at the beginning of all this, because many people came home not properly screened. They came home with mismatched organs. They came home very sick with HIV and Hep-C and other problems.

So India kind of dropped out, Pakistan moved up, but the Israeli network is the most extensive, as I said, in terms of its organizational power, is quite incredible. And I've worked with investigators in Brazil, in Turkey and in South Africa, and they were broken up there. The United States was resistant.

CONAN: They were all elements of this same organization. Nancy Scheper-Hughes, we were talking about this organization before. You said that in various parts of the world ~ in South Africa, Brazil, Turkey ~ officials were willing to act much more quickly. Why not so quickly here in the United States?

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: I don't know because I did report, I think it's been in the newspapers, on the Brooklyn brokers to ~ at the request of public-health officials in New York. I always work through public health and transplant professionals. They said this is beyond our reach. You're talking about an international network. We'd like you to talk to this special agent.

And I really puzzled over it. I'd never done anything like that before, but I did sit down with an FBI agent in 2002 and said this is the information I have. I have it from the mouths of people who have used this person. I have it also from transplant surgeons who were very worried about this in Israel. I'd made several trips to Israel and said, you know, this really is hurting us. It's hurting, you know, our own transplant profession here.

It's not a good thing. But nothing was done, and when I reported to ministry of health in Turkey, Moldova and Brazil and South Africa ~ all doing different things in the network. Some of the places, like Brazil, were being tapped for nice, fresh donors, you know, poor men living in the slums who were unemployed.

And in Turkey, it was one of the sites of operation. That is where patients would come from Israel, and in that case, the donors were being procured from collapsed agricultural villages in Moldova. And I went to Moldova and found out that over 300 men ~ at that point in my investigation, I'm sure there are many more now ~ in several villages of Moldova, had been recruited by brokers, local kidney hunters, and then passed on to higher-up brokers, trafficked to Turkey, and then some of them even came into New York City.

And, quite incredible to me, I spoke to the ambassador ~ American ambassador in Moldova at that time. I think he was an interim ambassador, and he said we need to report this to visa control because these men are being brought in by brokers. They're impoverished. Their shoes are ~ you know, they don't have proper clothing on. They look malnourished in some cases, and they're going to New York City as tourists.

He said it didn't make any sense. So we finally decided to stop that, even though they would often have $100 in their pocket. You know, the brokers would give them some money and say, you know, you have money. You have a relative that you're visiting, and the relative would be a broker in Brooklyn or in Philadelphia.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Unfortunately, I should tell you there are ways that are very problematic, and I think you would agree. There was, until I closed it down, a Web site in China that would sell livers and ~ even from living people, but mostly from executed prisoners. And selling a half of your liver is not something that any righteous transplant surgeon would take part in, in taking a half of a liver.

That's something that a very dear, close loved one who's totally screened and taken care of and protected afterward. You don't just take a stranger and take a half a liver and send them back to a slum somewhere in the world.

CONAN: You mentioned a Chinese Web site. Russell(ph), on email from Tulsa, emails to ask: Is there any known case of organ trafficking over a popular U.S. Internet outlet, such as Craigslist, eBay, Facebook, MySpace, et cetera?

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Yes, of course there is, yes. I spoke to a young man not more than a month ago who was desperately seeking a kidney and was not doing well on dialysis. Some people can stay ~ I've known people, 20 years on dialysis who have managed okay. Some people can't tolerate it. In his distress, he thought of two possible options. And he listed on Craigslist and had people that were willing to do it, but it was 30,000 and above ~ 40,000 I think ~ and he was trying to bring it down.

His other option was going to Iran. He had some distant relations in Iran. And Iran is the only country that has a regulated sale-of-kidneys program. It's problematic, but it was done with great ~ good intentions 15 years ago. So they've been running this. It's only for Iranians, and it's only buying and selling within Iran. And it's handled by a patients' rights organization, but it still has problems.

CONAN: There is - the only way to avert these lists that we're talking about is if you can bring someone in, a friend or a relative, who can say I want to give my kidney, half my liver, whatever, to this friend, this relative. And that's the only way you can avoid waiting on the lists, the official lists, Nancy?

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Well, I just came back recently from France, at a very large transplant conference that included people from the Council of Europe and from WHO and French transplant professionals. And, you know, in Europe, the waiting lists are not like the United States and they do it with deceased donors. They do it via presumed consent. I don't like the term presumed consent. Nothing should be presumed about what one does and how one disposes one's self and one's body either alive or dead. But I think we could call something like universal donation, unless you have reservations that could be based on a number of…

CONAN: It's an opt-out thing as opposed to here it works…

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: An opting out.

CONAN: …as an opt-in.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: An opting out.

CONAN: Yeah.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: And it does work well in Europe. And only seven percent of all kidney transplants in France are done with living donors. In many parts of Europe ~ and I've been to Portugal and Spain ~ they do not like asking living people. Of course, we know people can live well with one kidney. Some people are born with one kidney. But they don't think it's proper. I refer to green donation versus red donation. I think of recycling the bodies of the dead as green and as more appropriate than making an individual go through ~ I've observed many living donor ~ It's a very, very onerous operation and…

CONAN: As I understand it, though, a living donor, a kidney from a living donor or, indeed, any other organ, the recipient will do better if it's a living donor.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Well, that would be true if it was a heart, too. But unfortunately, we can't take a fresh heart from a person.

You know, these are moral issues. I don't think that it should be a tax on a body of the living to do this until we're positive we've done everything to set up an efficient donor system.

CONAN: Mm-hmm.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: And UNOS has been a wonderful organization, but it has been very, very reluctant to go with the notion of opting out. They just feel that the American temperament, personality ~ they're not going to want that because they'll feel it's government intervention in some sense in your lives that, no, I don't even own my own body.

CONAN: Yeah.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: But since it does work so well in Europe and does so little damage and potential harm to people who are donors~ I mean, it's a serious operation.

I mean ~ and to say that a living kidney is better than a deceased kidney is part of what's driven people to be transplant tourists. I've heard many of the transplant tourists who travel, say, I don't want to ask this of a loved one. I'd rather buy from a stranger. And so, it actually suppresses the donation among loved ones, which is moral, ethical and, you know, a beautiful act. But to buy from a stranger, who you have no responsibility to and you don't care what happens to them afterward, is really entering into an ethical and moral gray zone.

We're talking about the market in human organs here in the United States with Nancy Scheper-Hughes. You're listening to TALK OF THE NATION from NPR News.

CONAN: And, Nancy Scheper-Hughes, before we let you go, you've talked about this one Israeli-based organization. Are there others that you think you know about, or just ~ or is it more locally involved operations around the rest of the country?

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Well, there's many, many operations that are specific to Egypt and Turkey, China, India, Pakistan. Pakistan is very ~ excuse me, I have something in my throat.

CONAN: That's okay. Take a moment and cough it out.

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: So, you know, I think I can't… I have a touch of asthma and I think I'm reacting right now.

CONAN: Well, Nancy, then we're going to have to let you go and thank you for your time. We don't want to certainly…

Dr. SCHEPER-HUGHES: Thank you.

1 comment:

  1. Hi and thank for the great job you did .
    I live in France where a heavy censorship is held over anything zionists don't like . So I was following the Trenton trial , but I have never be able to find the epilogue of this trial .
    Is that the rabbI was sentenced and what was the final condemnation?
    Thank you for any reply, my E-mail : charliedestartinn /Arob/


If your comment is not posted, it was deemed offensive.